The Coloniality Of Gender And Sexuality

Wixárika women and gender in the Indigenous 21st Century

The late 20th Century and first decades of the 21st Century saw structural changes impact life in Wixárika communities.

Vehicle access was first cut into the highlands in the 1980s and little by little more villages have been connected to mestizo towns and cities, although it would be almost four decades before any of these roads were paved. Ease of access in and out of the highlands has seen more women and men migrate to sell their artwork, study or work on agricultural plantations.

Women selling woven bags and bead jewellery at artisan market, Nueva Colonia 2016

Although not without controversy, the new millennium brought electricity, gradually connecting most towns and hamlets with mains or solar power. Primary level health clinics were provided with ambulances and doctors working in the highlands learned that more people would use the services if they were open to Wixárika ways. Allowing mara’akate or local shamans into the clinic to assist with births fosters trust and encourages women to use the services, while bilingual nurses, doctors and health promoters support women and men with translation.

Social development programmes have largely focused on women because of their domestic and child-care role, reinforcing patriarchal gender stereotypes. However these cash payments have put money in women’s pockets and grocery and general stores began to flourish. The bonus payments given for each girls school attendance school saw an increase in female literacy and now nearly equal numbers of boys and girls finish primary and secondary school. Many girls now also continue to bachelorette or university and although some stay to work in cities and towns, many return to their highland homes and are employed locally as teachers, doctors or engineers.

Crusade against hunger

Woman also run shops in their communities as well as making chaquira -bead jewellery- and are able to buy cloth for making clothes, creating demand for haberdasheries, stationers and tortillerias. These changes have come alongside greater participation in the traditionally masculine public domain of politics and leadership.

Woman also run shops in their communities as well as making chaquira -bead jewellery- and are able to buy cloth for making clothes, creating demand for haberdasheries, stationers and tortillerias. These changes have come alongside greater participation in the traditionally masculine public domain of politics and leadership.

Crusade against hunger

Many women talked about the role of education in changing the lives of women and girls in their communities. 

“It was frowned upon for women to talk back to men… that’s what we learned from the adults who told us that when we got married the man would be our parent and responsible for keeping us, so a woman couldn’t talk back to him or it could go bad. So we just put up with it” (Etsiama, 2021)
School and tumini (money) have given them a degree of freedom that they have not had before. Fewer men take a second or subsequent wife and with some degree of financial support women feel able to leave their husbands if they are treated poorly.

Four Generations

Women And Social Actions

01

Women queuing for their Prospera conditional welfare payments.

In 2016 Wixárika communities were once again under pressure from national and state level institutions to change the governance and internal organisation of their communities. This time the changes were about gender.

When the post-revolutionary state brought in agricultural reform, ejidos were brought under the Ministry for Agriculture and all community members were to be registered. In 2016 it came to the attention of the Ministry for Agriculture that very few Wixárika women were listed on their communal land register and communities were ordered to change this. This top-down state led requirement brought gender to the discussion table in the community of Tuapurie. A series of changes aimed at addressing historical gender inequalities, including establishing a community women’s commission within their governance structure and making it easier for women to hold ejido land titles were brought in.

Wimari Women’s health collective 2016: Yolanda, Claudia with daughter Monterrat, Sauwi , Jovita and baby Brisa América)

From 2013-2016 the  Wimari Women’s health collective worked across Tuapurie to gather experiences of pregnancy and childbirth and organised community events aimed at improving maternal and infant health outcomes (findings from this research can be found here ***this should be a link to publications***)

For some women this was their first experience of speaking at a community meeting. Women are now increasingly taking on roles in the traditional government and with many more completing high school and university, they have a greater capacity to challenge men in private and public spaces.

Women also told the Tuapurie Oral History project about how education and interventions such as gender equality training had played crucial roles in increasing their participation in the public and political life of their community.

“Well, I think it’s because of the study, the school. Now women have more knowledge.” (Lucia, 2022)

Pues yo creo que es por el estudio, la escuela. Ahora las mujeres ya tienen más conocimiento.

“Well, it’s the teiwarixi [mestizo/non indigenous people] who are involved in all that. Because the phrase “woman has the same values as a man” is from the teiwarixi and they have trained women to defend themselves” (Lucia, 2022)
“Pues más bien son los teiwarixi los que están interviniendo en todo eso. Porque la frase “la mujer tiene los mismos valores que un hombre” es de los teiwarixi y pues han entrenado a las mujeres para que se defienda”

From 2014-2018  The Wimari collective worked with women throughout Tuapurie to understand what problems women were experiencing in relation to pregnancy, birth and infant survival.

"For example, they told me 'put yourself in the hands of the ancestors. If you haven’t committed adultery and you have confessed, you are well to have children, the birth will go without problem, and well I always left my life in the hands of ancestors without knowing if I was going to do well. ... That's why I abandoned him [my husband], he always messes with other women, then he brought another woman home, then another. Not anymore! Because of his infidelity, several of my children died” (Rosa, 2021).

 In 2016 they worked with artists to make life size hangings of the nine months of pregnancy. These are on display in the community.

Women also told the Tuapurie Oral History Project that relationships with their ancestors, gender inequality and adultery all play a role in maternal and infant wellbeing.

Nine months of pregnancy made by the Wimari collective, 2016

The cash payments that women received from the Prospera welfare programme were conditional on children’s school attendance and participation in exercise sessions and health promotion talks. Delia from the Wimari project talked about how she used her role as translator for the doctors and nurses to organise a campaign to change treatment at the health clinic that was making it harder for women to meet the conditionality and attend medical appointments.

Women talking, Nueva Colonia 2016

The textile cooperative Fábrica Social worked with Wimari to run training sessions for women on how to calculate the value of their work.

“Well, it is us who are changing things. Before they said that women were useless, but we have always contributed as much as men, then they started to say that women have the same value as men and now they are giving more [political] roles to women’

(Lucia, 2022)

Women also told the Tuapurie Oral History Project about how they are now changing things as they know their value.

Learning how to calculate a living wage with Fábrica Social.

A New Female Leader

02

Maria Concepción Bautista was appointed as the first ever President for Communal Property for Tuapurie in 2022.

"For example, they told me 'put yourself in the hands of the ancestors. If you haven’t committed adultery and you have confessed, you are well to have children, the birth will go without problem, and well I always left my life in the hands of ancestors without knowing if I was going to do well. ... That's why I abandoned him [my husband], he always messes with other women, then he brought another woman home, then another. Not anymore! Because of his infidelity, several of my children died” (Rosa, 2021).

This brings to an end more than 250 years of male leadership. In this role Maria Concepción is responsible for representing her community with municipal, state and federal authorities. She will enter discussions as an Indigenous woman in an environment dominated by mestizo men.

Gazing at the event

Over the decades social and welfare projects have come and gone, bringing different benefits and constraints to Wixárika communities.

“Well, it is us who are changing things. Before they said that women were useless, but we have always contributed as much as men, then they started to say that women have the same value as men and now they are giving more [political] roles to women’ (Lucia, 2022) “Pues nosotros mismos somos los que estamos cambiando las cosas, y porque antes se decia que las mujeres no serviamos para nada, pero siempre hemos aportado igual que los hombres, luego empezaron a decir que las mujeres tenemos el mismo valor que los hombres, y por eso se les ha estado dando mas cargos a las mujeres…….

In 2022 the Plan de Justicia (Justice Plan), a development programme for the for the Gran Nayar region, was signed with leaders from Cora, Tepehuan, Wixárika and Mexicanero Indigenous communities.

Although the plan recognises the problems of gender equality and violence against women, the proposal to resolve these issues with gender equality workshops and actions to promote and guarantee the rights of Indigenous women do not go nearly far enough. In continuity with previous Indigenous development programmes these proposals reflect the absence of women’s voices in their design, with political decisions still being made man-to-man, as they were in the colonial era.

Signing of the Justice Plan

“Well, it is us who are changing things. Before they said that women were useless, but we have always contributed as much as men, then they started to say that women have the same value as men and now they are giving more [political] roles to women’ (Lucia, 2022) “Pues nosotros mismos somos los que estamos cambiando las cosas, y porque antes se decia que las mujeres no serviamos para nada, pero siempre hemos aportado igual que los hombres, luego empezaron a decir que las mujeres tenemos el mismo valor que los hombres, y por eso se les ha estado dando mas cargos a las mujeres…….
The coloniality of gender is an ongoing process that cannot be addressed with small scale or time limited interventions, however the appointment of Maria Concepción Bautista to the role of President for Communal Property for Tuapurie, the highest-ranking position in their traditional government brings a historic opportunity for women to recover their authoritative role in their community.

Maria Concepción Bautista taking office

The ceremonial ‘cambio de varas’ ceremony in January 2023 when Maria Concepción Bautista took office.

Attitudes to sexuality are also changing and men and women in same sex relationships are also getting organised.

“Well, it is us who are changing things. Before they said that women were useless, but we have always contributed as much as men, then they started to say that women have the same value as men and now they are giving more [political] roles to women’ (Lucia, 2022) “Pues nosotros mismos somos los que estamos cambiando las cosas, y porque antes se decia que las mujeres no serviamos para nada, pero siempre hemos aportado igual que los hombres, luego empezaron a decir que las mujeres tenemos el mismo valor que los hombres, y por eso se les ha estado dando mas cargos a las mujeres…….

Adolfo De La Torre Carrillo, pictured here with his sister Claudia who led the Tuapurie Oral History Project, recently initiated ‘Ta niuki LGBT Wixárika’ the first LGBT group for Wixaritari and he runs a youtube channel with videos on LGBT activism.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Email

Delia:

…and there I realised how the doctor and health promoter were treating them [the women]…She would say to them ‘let’s see señoras, what was this talk about?’ And the women who knew were given their attendance mark but those who didn’t know were marked as absent. This was in every talk that were given and so, when it was my turn to translate, instead I asked the women:

Is this good or bad for you? What do you think?
Shall we do something, or write a complaint, or make a list of those of us who disagree with this and of those who have been badly treated?

The doctor started insisting we make appointments, then if you didn’t make it at the right time she would not see you, so she would give you an appointment on another day or month. Some women had to walk several hours from the valley to be seen and the doctor would make them walk to make their appointment then come back to be seen. So we decided to get organised, we had a meeting with all of the women who were in Prospera and made a list, we gave the list of all our names to the authorities. Then we wrote six letters, one each to the education, health and development ministries, to the state governor, the CDI (Commission for Indigenous Development) and the Mayor. We demanded that they all come to our Community for a meeting and we organised a series of protests together with the community authorities… this all happened because I asked the women what they thought of the service we were receiving…

Who are we?

This exhibition showcases the findings from Gender, health and the Afterlife of Colonialism: engaging new problematisations to improve maternal and Infant Survival, a Wellcome Trust Funded research project (Project number 215001/Z/18/Z).

We have used archive searches, revision of bibliographical material and interviews as part of the Tuapurie Oral History Project to understand how gender has changed through contact between the colonial State and later independent Mexican Republic and Wixárika indigenous communities.

The project is a collaboration between:

University College London (UCL), Institute for Global Health

CIESAS Occidente (the Centre for Research and Studies in Social Anthropology) 

Conservación Humana AC (CHAC) 

And members of the The Wixárika Community of Tuapurie, Mezquitic, Jalisco.

Project Director
Dr. Jennie Gamlin,
Associate Professor, Medical Anthropology and Global Health, UCL Institute for Global Health.
view profile
j.gamlin@ucl.ac.uk

Exhibition Curator
Humberto Fernández Borja,
Conservación Humana A.C.
http://www.chac.org.mx

Archive Research team director
Dr. María Teresa Fernández Aceves
view profile

Archive Research team leader
Dr. Paulina Ultreras Villagrana
view profile

Archival Research
Ileana Cristina Gómez Ortega
Tania Fernanda Aguilar Silva
Frine Castillo Badillo

Field work director
Totupica Candelario Robles

Field work assistant
Claudia de la Torre Carrillo

Animation
Susie Vickery
http://www.susievickery.com/

Curatorial, image research and production assistants
Ana Laura Mejía Ruiz Esparza
Daniela Guraieb Elizalde
Lorena Silva Lordméndez
Daniela Altamirano Visoso
Anaïs Oropeza Jochum
Hiromi Amador Hosoya

Contact:
Jennie Gamlin: j.gamlin@ucl.ac.uk
Institute for Global Health,
30 Guilford St., London, WC1N 1EH.

Funding:
We would like to thank The Wellcome Trust for funding this project as part of a Research Enrichment-Public Engagement award.

Image credits

We would like to thank the following organisations and individuals for gifting materials and copies of materials that have been used in this exhibition

Ivan Alechine

American Museum of Natural History Library for gifting prints from the Carl Lumholtz Collection to the CHAC Archive

Archivo General de Indias
[General Archive of the Indies]

Archivo Histórico de Jalisco
[Historical Archive of Jalisco]

Archivo Fotográfico del Instituto Cultural de Aguascalientes
[Photographic Archive of the Aguascalientes Cultural Institute]

Biblioteca Pública del Estado de Jalisco “Juan José Arreola” de la Universidad de Guadalajara,
[Public Library of the State of Jalisco “Juan José Arreola” at the University of Guadalajara]

Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University.

CHAC Archive: : C/O Humberto Fernández Borja. Conservación Humana AC
CHAC-Lilly Archive: C/O Humberto Fernández Borja. Conservación Humana AC

Catholic Church Records, 1590-1979, Mezquitic, Jalisco, Mexico.
[Registros Parroquiales, Mezquitic, Jalisco]

Fundación Cultural Armella Spitalier

Instituto Nacional Indigenista
[National Indigenous Institute]

Museo Zacatecano – Instituto Zacatecano de Cultura Ramón López Velarde